The Sigmund Freud theory of religion explores the psychological roots of religious belief. Freud questioned the origins and meaning of religious ideas, suggesting they stem from deep psychological conflicts and traumatic historical events. He argued that belief systems emerged as a response to the emotional struggles rooted in the Oedipus complex, representing one of humanity’s earliest moral crises. Many classical theories of religion, especially those influenced by psychology, build on these ideas. Whether focused on spirituality or organized religion, Freud’s theory continues to shape research in sociology, psychology, and the scientific study of belief.
Religious conflicts in the media highlight the paradoxical role of religion, simultaneously fostering prejudice and promoting altruistic and helping behavior, as noted by G.W. Alport. The need for robust theories in the psychology of religion is evident. Psychology must engage with religious issues to demonstrate its relevance to a culture seeking guidance from science and nature. Transpersonal psychology challenges the boundaries between science and spiritual discipline.
Psychoanalysis theory and religion
Freud’s psychology of religion involves two related theories. Firstly, the ontogenic theory links individual piety to infantile helplessness and the longing for protection from the omnipotent father. The superego substitutes for the father, influencing men more, who then shape religion and pass it on to women. Religious rituals serve as a defense against various impulses akin to obsessional neurosis.
Secondly, the phylogenetic theory considers men as the originators of religious traditions. Most founders and reformers of religions are male, and male dominance persists among religious leaders. Gardner Murphy emphasizes Freud’s epic view of human nature, prioritizing artistic congruity and power over internal consistency. Freud’s psychoanalysis, though based on observation, contains elements of tragicomedy, reflecting the struggle between primitive passions and civilization’s victories rooted in early childhood preoccupations.
Freud didn’t merely eliminate religious observance but analyzed it within his general theory. He viewed religion as psychology projected into the external world, explaining myths, gods, evils, immortality, and more.
Religion as neurosis
Religion and neurosis share some similarities. Both involve specific actions done carefully, without interruptions, causing anxiety when neglected. However, unlike neurotic rituals, religious ceremonies are done together with others in the community.
In religious ceremonies, every action has a meaningful purpose. Still, regular worshipers might need help understanding why they do what they do, just like in neurosis, where people may need to know why they perform certain actions. Freud, a famous psychologist, believed that neurotic rituals come from repressed sexual feelings. Similarly, he thought that religion forms when people suppress certain natural instincts. So, according to Freud, religion can be seen as a kind of “obsessional neurosis,” and neurosis can be thought of as a distorted, personal form of religion.
Religion precarious future
Religion’s future is still being determined. Some people think about it a lot. Freud, a famous thinker, talked about it. He said religion could be an illusion, but he didn’t mean believers are tricked. Instead, he wanted to show that human wishes play a big part in why people believe in and practice religion.
According to him, the roots of religious feelings go back to when people were very young, needing their mother’s care and, later, their father’s protection.
Religion masculine roots: sons & fathers
Religion’s origins, according to Freud, are rooted in the relationship between sons and fathers, especially among males. Both sexes experience infantile helplessness, but Freud’s focus is clearly on masculine reactions. In Freud’s view, the core of religion lies in the male’s ambivalent connection with his father, both in individual and collective childhoods.
He believes that males led the way in developing religion, morality, and a sense of society, eventually passing these on to women through cross-inheritance.
Religion & Personality
Let’s delve into the topic of religion and personality. People’s personalities differ, leading to various beliefs and practices. Introverts and extroverts, for example, approach religion differently. Extroverts may actively participate in religious communities, while introverts may have a more personal faith.
Religion can provide comfort and guidance for people with different personality traits. It’s intriguing to explore how personality influences one’s religious experiences. Moreover, some individuals may have a strong connection between their personality traits and religious beliefs. This connection can shape their values and behaviors. For instance, personality traits may influence an individual’s beliefs about God’s role in the world. Extroverts might perceive God as more involved, while introverts may see God as less active.
Additionally, one’s upbringing and environment can influence their religious beliefs. A strong religious background may lead to intense religious experiences and conversions. Furthermore, the way people perceive their beliefs can vary. Some individuals may view their religious beliefs as absolute truths, while others may see them as personal interpretations.
In conclusion, personality traits, upbringing, and personal interpretations significantly shape one’s religious beliefs and experiences.
Conclusion
In conclusion, interpreting religious phenomena using psychoanalysis depends on one’s view of religion. If we believe religion has no objective validity, it’s seen as a product of human needs. However, perceiving a reality beyond human invention allows psychoanalysis to deepen religious faith. Freud was mainly interested in the origin of religion in the human race. He explored this extensively in his work.
Additionally, Freud noted similarities between neurotic rituals and religious practices. He argued that religious beliefs were illusions, not responses to reality. Later, he acknowledged the value of religious experiences. For Freud, mystical experiences were like regressions to an earlier, infantile state linked to beliefs in God. In his view, religious beliefs were not just illusions but also delusions.
Works Cited
Allport, Gordon W. The Nature of Prejudice. Cambridge Mass., Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, 1954.
Capps, Walter H. Religious Studies. Fortress Press, 1995.
Deal, William E, and Timothy K Beal. Theory for Religious Studies. New York, Routledge, 2004.
Gay, Peter. Freud : A Life for Our Time. New York, Norton, 2006.
Helm, Paul. Faith with Reason. Oxford, Clarendon Press ; Oxford ; New York, 2000.
Hood, Ralph W, et al. The Psychology of Religion : An Empirical Approach. New York, Ny, Guilford Press, 2018.
FQAs
1. What did Freud mean by calling religion an “illusion”?
Freud argued that religious beliefs are illusions—wish-fulfillments rooted in human desires, not reality. He believed they stem from an unconscious longing for protection and meaning, similar to a child’s dependency on a father figure.
2. Why did Freud compare religion to a neurosis?
Freud saw parallels between religious rituals and neurotic compulsions—both involve ritualistic, anxiety-driven behavior. He famously described religion as a “universal obsessional neurosis.” And “religion … arises out of a child’s need for comfort…”
3. How does the Oedipus complex explain the origin of religion?
Freud traced religion’s origins to the Oedipus complex and the primal horde. He theorized that early humans overthrew and killed a father-figure, and then projected guilt onto a totem or deity, creating rituals and taboos.
4. What is the “father-figure projection” theory?
Freud posited that the image of God reflects a projection of the father onto a divine being. Religious belief continues the child’s dependence on a paternal protector, extended into adulthood.
5. What is the “oceanic feeling” and how is it linked to religion?
Freud acknowledged a sense of unity with the universe—called the “oceanic feeling”—a regression to early infantile consciousness. He speculated that this feeling may be the root emotional source of religious experience.
6. Did Freud believe religion has a future?
In The Future of an Illusion (1927), Freud predicted religion would fade as reason and scientific understanding advance—much like outgrown childhood fantasies.
7. Did Freud see any positive role for religion?
While sharply critical, Freud recognized that religion played a role in social cohesion and controlling destructive impulses in early civilization. However, he maintained that modern society’s progress should rely on science and reason instead.
8. How are rituals and neurotic behavior similar?
Both religious and neurotic behaviors are anxiety-driven, symbolic, and involve specific, purposeful actions. Freud believed that religious rituals mirror an individual’s neurotic tendencies to manage psychological stress.
9. How do personality differences influence religious expression?
Freud and later psychoanalytic thinkers suggested that individual traits—such as introversion or extroversion—shape how people experience and practice religion .
✅ Summary
Freud approached religion as a natural psychological phenomenon:
- Illusory: born from unconscious desires
- Neurotic: similar to obsessive–compulsive behavior
- Projected: God as a paternal figure born from early trauma
- Eventually dispensable: science could replace religion’s functions
These FAQs capture the essence of Freud’s psychoanalytic interpretation of religion. Let me know if you’d like to explore one aspect further!
Known Psychology is a collaborative platform run by a dedicated team of psychology experts, professional writers, and experienced editors who are passionate about psychology and mental wellness. We publish evidence-based, easy-to-understand content designed to inform, inspire, and support our global audience. Every article is carefully researched and crafted to provide reliable insights into human behavior, emotional health, therapy techniques, and personal growth strategies. At Known Psychology, we turn complex psychological topics into simple, actionable knowledge.
